A few thoughts on editing young reporters for community news

After a few years of working closely with other reporters, I’ve found the points we most often talk about. Here’s a list.

  • Tell me something that matters with your lede.
  • Anecdotal ledes should follow through the narrative arc. That anecdote better be in your kicker too
  • Either a story I want or a lesson I need. Readers want a great story or something that can help them (preferably both)
  • Where is your nut graf? This always feels like what is most often missing. This is the pivot between a story and your point: what broader context brings this together?
  • Structure and pace are two different skillsets
  • Prepare headlines and stories for the wider social web. Help think through the tightest way to explain the importance of your story.
  • Allow your story to be focused locally and understood globally
  • That’s redundant, which means a waste of words, which is a sin.
  • Know what your news site believes in. Who is your audience? What is the worldview? What is the broader narrative this story fits in?
  • How could this story be told differently?
  • What would the reader most need? What would help the reader scan? Would bullet points help?
  • You haven’t earned long sentences; shorter sentences for pace
  • Move faster; ship product
  • Be flawless on grammar
  • Hyperbole and cliche is where imprecision lives
  • Human elements to give the reader a break from technical pieces
  • Lead with attribution on purpose, either for style or more likely because the source matters. otherwise, lead with the lesson. the attribution is the footnote.
  • Link for more information
  • Have a call to action and make it easy
  • When in doubt disclose. Transparency over all else

This column about Technical.ly was spiked by the Philadelphia Business Journal

Ahead of the fifth annual Philly Tech Week back in April, consultant and Drexel University chairman Stan Silverman, who writes a regular column for the Philadelphia Business Journal, decided to write about Technical.ly and my work there.

Unfortunately the Business Journal’s leadership flexed its editorial discretion and spiked the story. It wasn’t the first time we heard something about us was dropped by the publication — Silverman told me he never had a column idea killed like that before by his editor.

One can’t know exactly why but one might come to assume it’s a rather petty swipe at us, as they see us as a kind of competition. I hope we can all appreciate the irony that during this very same Philly Tech Week, we happily included and helped to promote a Business Journal event, their IT awards. Oh it’s too perfect.

I guess it’s just the difference between the open web and ugly legacy tendancies.

Read Silverman’s column, which he published on his personal site, here.