(Note, as a past P&P board member, I drafted an earlier history, and this reflects some updates from my friend Sandy Smith. In honor of the place surviving the pandemic, with a fair bit of financial help from many of us members, I wanted to finally share what I know about the place)
The Pen & Pencil Club has had more homes than Philadelphia had daily newspapers when it was founded in 1892. Its current and permanent home at 1522 Latimer Street is the Club’s 16th residence—a fitting end to more than a century of nomadic existence.
The Club’s journey began at 133 South 11th Street, where it occupied the second floor for two years before moving to Bohemian Hall in 1894. Bohemian Hall remained the Club’s longest home, housing it until 1926. Neither of these buildings exists today; Thomas Jefferson University’s hospital now occupies the 11th Street site, and its Scott Building has stood on the Bohemian Hall site since 1970.
The Club’s third home was its first owned property: a townhouse at 1023 Spruce Street, purchased in 1926 for $42,500. Unfortunately, the Club struggled financially during Prohibition and could not sustain mortgage payments, leading to foreclosure in 1936. The building was sold in the late 1930s for $11,500.
From there, the Club rented its next ten homes. Its fourth location was in the now-demolished Walton Hotel at 233-47 South Broad Street, which it occupied from 1937 to 1941. It then moved to 1522 Walnut Street, now home to Holt’s Cigar Company, where it remained through 1944.
In 1945, the Club moved to 1523 Locust Street. Tragically, a Christmas Day fire in 1946 destroyed much of the building and the Club’s records. By January 1947, the Club had relocated to 1615 Walnut Street, where it stayed for 16 months; a New Balance store now occupies this building.
The Club’s eighth home, from 1948 to 1954, was at 239-41 South 15th Street, which drew over 1,000 attendees, including Mayor Bernard Samuel and Governor James H. Duff, to its opening. The site was later demolished, and the Academy House condo tower now stands there.
Records indicate a brief and undocumented stay at 1305 Locust Street in 1954, followed by a move in 1955 to South Camac Street, a stretch once known as the “street of clubs.” This location, at 239-41 South Camac, was also the first home of the Poor Richard Club.
The Club’s next two homes are somewhat unclear. By February 1963, 216 South 16th Street was listed as its address, and it later appeared at 1709 Chestnut Street during the 1960s.
In 1967, the Club moved into its third-longest-lived home at 218 South 16th Street/1600 Chancellor Street, where it stayed for nearly two decades. In 1986, the Club purchased its second owned property at 563 North 15th Street, but financial struggles forced it to close this location in 1990.
The Club reopened later that year at 1623 Sansom Street, where it remained until 1995. This building has since been replaced by the structure housing Abe Fisher and Dizengoff restaurants.
Finally, on August 17, 1995, the Pen & Pencil Club purchased its current home at 1522 Latimer Street. This time, the Club found stability: its mortgage was paid off early, and the milestone was celebrated in 2015 when then-President Chris Brennan ceremonially burned the note.
After more than a century of relocations, the Pen & Pencil Club has firmly settled into its home—a testament to its resilience and enduring role as the nation’s oldest surviving press club.
