Unsympathetic as they may seem to many, elite workers are stuck in a rotten cycle.
They’ve gotten their status by obsessing over rarified education and lifelong work obsession. They then work to ensure their kids get the same or better advantage, ensuring the system continues.
If a century ago, we saw the end of an aristocratic elite that earned income idly through generational wealth and factories they rarely entered, then today the meritocratic elite earn income working 100 hours a week as a corporate executive, attorney, banker or perhaps true technology leader. There was a time when we thought we solved this: In the 1950s and 1960s, well-intentioned reformers at Ivy League schools introduced a wave of merit-based admissions, which temporarily balanced the scales. But then rich families began to adapt to the rules and now they dominate them.
Rich kids are still more likely to get to elite schools, and then win in elite careers — but they bludgeon themselves with work in a way that their great grandparents wouldn’t have.
This worsens the fate of middle class, who have no chance of breaking into elite educations that are further owned by the rich — not now by hereditary handoffs but by buying elite education — and ensures generational poverty stays so. The elite get the same outcome but at a far higher cost.
That’s the thrust of Yale Law legal scholar Daniel Markovits’s fall 2019 “The Meritocracy Trap: How America’s Foundational Myth Feeds Inequality, Dismantles the Middle Class, and Devours the Elite,” which I just read. Vox review from back then here.
No doubt his timing was tricky. As his book was published the covid-19 pandemic began to swell. It’s taken me this long to come back to the book, though it’s on one of my favorite topics. He wrote in his acknowledgements the book came from years of work, and in the book he says the final push came from this May 2015 commencement address he gave.
He’s a dazzling writer, with some wonderful turns of phrase, but he needs only half of them. I found myself marveling over a pretty sentence, only to notice that he was essentially reasserting the same point he had just made. Nonetheless, I enjoyed the myriad ways he introduced and reintroduced his concepts.
Below I share my own notes from the book for future reference.
Continue reading Meritocracy should be dismantled
